$818,231: The Opportunity Cost of the FIRE Movement

It’s difficult in 2023 to avoid trendy topics, regardless of their validity or sanity (I do my best but a part of me is always plugged in). A topic in recent years that’s garnered some attention on social media is the FIRE movement, or “financial independence, retire early” movement. The acronym is self-explanatory, but maybe what’s not so self-evident is what it costs to pursue.

When we think about money and our expenses, our brains jump to what our actual expenses are: rent, groceries, daily living, etc. Natural, right? But there are also expenses in our life that are intangible, but calculable: the cost of not doing something.

What’s the cost of choosing one path over the other?

In economics and even everyday life, this is known as “opportunity cost.” It’s the value of what you give up when you choose to do something else.

For example, if it takes me 1 hour to drive to work or 2 hours to take public transit and I choose the public transit, I save money on gas, but I double my travel time. Therefore, my opportunity cost is 1 hour plus the things I could’ve done during that hour instead of being on the bus.

So, how does all of this relate to the FIRE movement?

Skip ahead:

  1. What is the FIRE Movement?
  2. FIRE Movement Implications: An Example
  3. Conclusions

What is the FIRE Movement?

Proponents of the FIRE movement advocate for living below our means today and paying down debts to achieve “financial independence”, which theoretically allows us to retire “10-30 years earlier than normal”. The “retire early” component has probably the widest variations in definition, but most proponents of the movement do not believe it means laying on a beach sipping a cocktail every day at age 45.

Rather, they argue that an early retirement allows people to pursue their passions they had to put off during their working years or to spend more time raising their children and being “financially independent” allows them to achieve this lifestyle.

The “FI” Ain’t So Easy

It’s freeing to be in control of money instead of it controlling us.

The FIRE movement sounds great on the surface, right? It’s no wonder it’s become so popular amongst the Millennial and Gen Z generations in blogs, social media posts, and podcasts. Paying down debt is almost always a sound financial choice and living below our means is a definitive key to long-term financial prosperity.

To me, “financial independence” means that I have enough money attached to my name that I no longer need additional income to support myself. This means that I have enough cash on hand for the “(bleep), now what?” moments that will inevitably happen, enough cash for daily living, and the ability to tap my investment accounts if I need to. From my experience, the people who can actually do this are extremely few and far between.

The “RE” Ain’t So Easy, Either

Remember when we got to college, and we were given the triangle of choices? Sleep, grades, and social life? We could have any two we wanted, but not all three. Some of us tried valiantly to obtain all three but, as it turns out, the human body actually needs sleep in order to function coherently. Who knew?

In my experience talking to clients who are thinking about retirement, a similar triangle of choices is present, but it looks a little different (shocker: partying til 3am isn’t on the triangle). Their triangle tends to have “where, when, and how much” on it and most commonly, retirees choose where they want to retire and how much money they need to sustain them, and those two choices determine the age they can call it quits.

The FIRE movement is backwards: it targets the “when” but downplays the “how much” portion and doesn’t even consider the “where.”

Retiring many years before a “traditional” retirement age has pretty serious implications on many aspects of financial life, such as savings in qualified accounts (refer to a prior post if you don’t know what these are), health insurance, and Social Security earnings history, which we are about to explore. I’m going to assume I’ve achieved “financial independence” in the following example and will focus on the “retire early” implications, as I feel they are more dire.

FIRE Movement Implications: An Example

Let’s say I turned 50 today and retired from my career as a CFP® professional and I pursue an amateur golf career while giving golf lessons part-time for a little income. We’re really entering fantasy land here folks, but it’ll serve its purpose as an example.

We will use age 67 as my retirement age to compare, which is defined by the Social Security Administration (or SSA) as my “Full Retirement Age” (or FRA; this is true for everyone born 1960 or after). A spouse and kids will complicate things so for purposes of this example, those situations are not considered.

All the assumptions used are based on Social Security numbers and are in a table below, and all calculations were done in an Excel file which can be made available upon request.

DataAssumptions
Birth year1972
Start working1994
Current age50
“Normal” retirement age67
Death age92
1994 salary (using SSA avg wage index)$23,754
2022 salary (using SSA avg wage index)$59,003
COLA for PIA (avg % 1975-2022)4%
Annual salary increase3.3%
File for Social SecurityAge 67, FRA
Investment growth rate6%
Note: “PIA” stands for Primary Insurance Amount, which is “the benefit (before rounding down to next lower whole dollar) a person would receive if he/she elects to begin receiving retirement benefits at his/her normal retirement age”, per the SSA.

Who Cares If I Retire At 50?

Well, as it turns out, the U.S. government and the SSA care when I retire. There are magical ages in the tax code that determine eligibility for things like tapping our retirement accounts, Medicare, and Social Security and if we don’t meet these requirements, we get a very costly slap on the wrist.

For example, we are not allowed to tap our qualified accounts (401ks and IRAs) before age 59.5 without paying income taxes and a 10% penalty (there are always exceptions, but this is a broad point). This is the first slap.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, only 44% of Americans actually have work retirement plans, and for the vast majority of these people, that will be their largest accumulating asset during their working years. Not having the ability to access our largest asset forces us to: have access to large amounts of cash on hand for emergencies and daily living (which inflation erodes over time), keep our debt balances to only necessary and manageable entities (autos and mortgage), and not withdraw money from any taxable investments we may have, as this severely hinders their ability to compound growth.  

But don’t take my word for it: let’s see what the numbers say.

What Happens to My Retirement Accounts?

Retiring at age 50 as opposed to age 67 means I miss out on 17 years of not only higher wages, but also retirement plan contributions. This is related to the first slap, but it might not be on my wrist: it might be in my face.

For example, at age 50, if I contribute 10% of my salary per year into a Roth 401k then I miss out on over $141,000 of completely tax-free money in retirement, not including growth on those dollars.

The story gets worse if my employer offers a match.

A common thing for employers to do is match half of our contribution up to 6% of our salary. Think of it as them basically saying, “You’re smart and a good employee, and we want to keep you, so here’s a little Scooby Snack,” and they kick in a little money in an effort to retain us. This money has never been taxed so it goes into a pre-tax Regular 401k and we have to pay taxes when we eventually withdraw it after age 59.5.

The employer 401k match is essentially “free money” that I leave on the table. In total, retiring 17 years early means I miss out on $184,000 of tax-advantaged dollars, and when the investment growth is factored in…

What Happens to My Health Insurance?

Now, when we’re employed, we don’t really care about health insurance costs because our employers cover them (thanks team!). Once we turn 65, the government provides our health insurance through Medicare. But if there’s a gap when we are not employed and are not yet age 65 (like in our example), then we are on the hook for private insurance. This is the second slap.

According to ValuePenguin, the average cost of private health insurance for a 50-year-old individual in 2022 was $734/month, or $8,808/year. Health insurance premiums have also increased 3.7% per year over the last 15 years, on average. In our example, if I retire at 50 and am on the hook for private insurance until Medicare at 65, it will cost me over $187,080. Ouch!

Health insurance is most expensive after age 50. Source: ValuePenguin and the federal age rating formula.

However, if I stayed employed and instead took that $734 per month and invested it at the same 6% growth as my Roth 401k, I would have roughly $213,461 at age 65. I have healthcare in both instances, but my opportunity cost of retiring at 50 is the delta between the two scenarios…a whopping $400,541.

What Happens to My Social Security Benefits?

I’m kind of tired of getting slapped, but here comes a third one.

We pay into Social Security out of every one of our paychecks so that when we reach a certain age, we receive a paycheck back for the rest of our lives (yes, it will still be there for us when we retire). The SSA uses our 35 highest earning years to calculate our monthly benefit for life. If we don’t work at least 35 years, then they use $0 to average in for the years we did not work.

Let’s say for purposes of our hypothetical, when I retire at 50 and give golf lessons on the side, I earn 30% of what I was making as a CFP® professional. I’ll project this out until age 67 to determine my monthly benefit, and then compare it to what it would have been had I stayed in my career until age 67. Then I project that out until age 92 to determine a lifetime Social Security benefit in each scenario.

I’m using age 92 because a general prophylactic in the financial planning world is to plan to live much longer than you might expect to, even though the SSA has a male life expectancy at birth of 76 years old. It’s better to have money when you die than to not have it while you’re alive.

The popular financial modeling software MoneyGuidePro uses the Society of Actuaries mortality tables to determine planning ages, and they recommend to plan to age 92 for a male, non-smoker, in good health with about average family longevity. So, what happens to my lifetime benefits if I miss out on 17 years of higher earnings?

Yeah, Yeah, Cut To The Chase…

If all that slapping didn’t wake up my hypothetical 50-year-old self, then I’ll break it down further so it will.

This example shows how easy it is to miss out on over three quarters of a million dollars by retiring from a full-time career 17 years early. It’s also self-evident to see how this number would be exacerbated if a spouse and kids are in the picture.

Paying this opportunity cost affects not only “future me” but also my family members or other heirs who may need an inheritance. I think it’s important to most of us that we financially support not only ourselves but also people we love and care about.

Conclusions

I didn’t create this example to say that no one can retire at 50, or 55, or any age that’s considered “early.” If the earnings history is large enough and the debt management is supreme, then it may be possible for a minority of people to enjoy an early retirement.

The example simply uses average United States statistics for investment growth, health insurance, and Social Security to show what’s given up by retiring from a full-time career at an early age. As it turns out, that number being left on the table is pretty large and can make or break a lot of financial plans.

If you’re considering pursuing FIRE, weigh the pros and cons of both financial and non-financial aspects of the decision. Use this example if it helps to understand the financial impacts of an early retirement and determine if the opportunity cost is worth paying.

How to Use a Health Savings Account to Crush Retirement

I’m not old, but I definitely plan on getting there some day (don’t worry, I’m not going to define what age “old” is). Just like anyone else, I have dreams and visions of retiring and spending time with loved ones, playing golf every day, or doing absolutely nothing on a beach in Tenerife.

All that is well and good, but what about the times when I’m not able to do the things I enjoy because of health needs?

A recent study by the Employee Benefits Research Institute found that a couple retiring in 2022 needs about $273,000 to cover medical expenses throughout retirement, and that does not include long-term care costs. I’m certainly not naïve enough to think I won’t be sidelined at some point in my life because of a health issue. So, how do I plan for that inevitability and the associated costs?

This is where the Health Savings Account, or an HSA, comes into play. Let’s first do a brief overview of the health insurance world and how an HSA ties into it, and then what we can do to take advantage of all of it.

Already a pro? Read what pertains to you:

  1. Health Insurance Basics
  2. What is a High-Deductible Health Plan (HDHP)?
  3. What is a Health Savings Account (HSA)?
  4. HSA Examples
  5. So, How Do I Take Advantage of an HSA?

Health Insurance Basics

The basic components of a health insurance policy are referenced multiple times throughout this article so it’s helpful to first establish some definitions:

Deductible: Amount paid by us before the insurance kicks in ($500 for example)

Coinsurance: Percentage of expenses covered by our insurance (80% for example)

Maximum out-of-pocket (MOOP): This is the max amount we will pay out of our own pockets for medical expenses and our insurance will cover 100% of future expenses ($5,000 for example)

Note: All these numbers relate to a calendar year.

What Is a High-Deductible Health Plan (HDHP)?

Congress proved they can keep things simple when they came up with this name.

This is health insurance that simply has a higher deductible than other insurance plans, which means we’re on the hook for more of our medical expenses. Monthly premiums are lower to compensate for the potentially higher out-of-pocket medical expenses.

“Aren’t we just gambling and hoping we don’t need to go to the doctor since we’ll have to pay more?” I can feel you asking me this and the answer is: sort of. But there’s a huge advantage to having a HDHP: we are granted the magical powers of an HSA.

What is a Health Savings Account (HSA)?

As far as the tax code is concerned, an HSA actually does have magical powers because it’s triple tax-advantaged: contributions to it are deductible, these contributions grow tax-free, and distributions for qualified medical expenses are tax-free. There’s nothing else like it.

We’re only allowed to have an HSA if we also have a HDHP. Our health insurance provider (usually paid for by our employer) maintains the HDHP, and a custodian (think Fidelity) maintains our HSA and provides the ability to invest.

We must be under Medicare eligibility age (age 65) and cannot be covered by any other health plan to be HSA-eligible. We are also not allowed to be eligible to be claimed as a dependent by someone else (notice the requirement is eligibility, not actually being claimed).

The contribution limit is set by the IRS every year, which can be found here. For 2023, it is $3,850 for an individual and $7,750 for a family. There is also a catch-up contribution of $1,000 allowed for individuals age 55 and over for both plans.

HSA Features

We’ll talk about funding/distribution strategies in the next section, but let’s first check out some of the cool things that an HSA can do:

  1. The list of “qualified medical expenses” was greatly expanded in 2022 to include all expenses that qualify for a medical deduction (go here to check out the full list)
  2. Distributions for these qualified expenses are tax-free
    • However, if we take money out of our HSA before age 65 and it is not for qualified expenses, we will pay ordinary income tax plus a 20% penalty on the distribution
  3. There is no statute of limitations, meaning we can contribute money in 2023 and leave it invested in the account until 2063 if we wanted (completely tax-free!)
  4. At retirement, HSA funds can be used to pay for things like COBRA premiums, long-term care premiums, and prescription drugs
  5. Any money in the account we don’t use is carried forward indefinitely until a named beneficiary ultimately inherits it

HSAs are dependent on good recordkeeping. We need to have receipts that match our medical expenses, so we don’t get hit with taxes and penalties on an expense that the IRS doesn’t consider “qualified.” If we can’t prove that we paid for that bottle of Tylenol at Target with our HSA funds…smack!

Pros vs. Cons of an HSA

An HSA is about as close to a free lunch as Congress will ever allow. There are many upsides to HSAs but like all other things in the tax code, there are trade-offs. Writing out a pros vs. cons list is a helpful visual to see if an HSA could be beneficial in your situation.

HSA Examples

Let’s take all these numbers and rules and put them into practical, real-world examples of how the HDHP + HSA combo functions. We’ll be using an individual HDHP in our examples, but the family HDHP works the same way with higher limits.

There are several ways we can take advantage of HSA funds: the way Congress intended (annual reimbursement) and the way Congress didn’t foresee (delayed reimbursement). The latter strategy is a healthcare “life hack” that can pay yourself some serious dividends if utilized properly.

The Way Congress Intended

Let’s take a single, 30-year-old individual named Sam as our example. Sam’s HDHP limits and 2023 expenses are as follows:

Deductible: $1,500

Coinsurance: 80%/20%

Maximum out-of-pocket (MOOP): $8,000

Qualified expenses: $10,000

Sam is on the hook for the full deductible and 20% of all remaining expenses up to $8,000. Let’s see how that adds up:

SamInsurance
Deductible$1,500$0
Coinsurance$1,700 (20% x $8,500)$6,800 (80% x $8,500)
Total$3,200$6,800

Sam would be allowed to reimburse himself for his out-of-pocket expenses, which in this example is $3,200. He cannot claim these expenses as an itemized deduction, however.

This is a great, tax-advantaged way to fund your healthcare expenses if you’re able to contribute to an HSA. Assuming a 25% tax rate, Sam would save $800 in taxes because he was able to pay the $3,200 with tax-free money. Pretty sweet for Sam!

The Way Congress Didn’t Foresee

This is where saving receipts and having good records really comes in handy.

As mentioned earlier, the IRS does not have a statute of limitations for using HSA funds, meaning there is no requirement to reimburse ourselves today for the medical expenses we incur. We can do it whenever we want! We can leave the funds invested in our HSA to compound growth and reimburse ourselves in 20, 30 or even 40 years from now.

If we can pay our medical expenses out of pocket today, our HSA ends up essentially being a 100% tax-free cash distribution in retirement that we can use for things like long-term care premiums, prescription drugs, or even that sweet vacation to Tenerife!

There are no guaranteed results with investing, but since the Great Depression nearly 95% of the 10-year rolling periods show positive returns. I like those odds if the future looks anything like the past.

The reason this works is because we saved our receipts and have records of our medical expenses, so when we take a distribution from our HSA, we can back it up with the appropriate medical expense and avoid income taxes and the 20% penalty if we’re under age 65.

Using Sam from our previous example, he would pay the $3,200 in expenses out of pocket and keep all the receipts. He’d leave his HSA funds invested in the account, which would compound growth until he reimburses himself in retirement 35 years later. Even sweeter for Sam!

So, How Do I Take Advantage of an HSA?

He doesn’t look worried about healthcare costs. Probably because he started an HSA when he was young.

Now that we have a better understanding of what an HSA is and what it can do, how do we take advantage of it?

If your employer offers a HDHP, a possibility is to negotiate for them to make the annual max HSA contribution as part of your compensation package. The insurance premiums will be lower, the contribution is deductible for them and not considered income to you, and it will help fund medical expenses for the “future you.” Everyone wins!

If your employer is unwilling to do this, look at your budget and set aside a dollar amount each paycheck to put into your HSA. Consider paying your medical expenses out of pocket if you can afford to and let your HSA funds grow over the long term.

In either case, remember that discipline is the most important trait needed to build wealth so come up with a plan, stick to it, and reap the rewards!

Payday: 4 Ways to Allocate a Year-End Bonus

Ahhh, it’s that time of year again. Colder weather (unless you live in California), seasons change (unless you live in California), and the holidays arrive (California still has those, thankfully). We can usually count on the last few months of the year to bring some excitement to our lives, whether it’s genuine excitement like seeing family we don’t normally see, or “drama” excitement…like seeing family we don’t normally see.

Probably best to not take your bonus to Vegas and put it all on red.

If we’re lucky, sometimes the end of the year brings us some sweet financial excitement, like a bonus from work or a healthy “I love you!” cash infusion from Gam-Gam. It’s nice to know people.

I get a lot of questions from friends and young professionals about what to do with this money when it comes in, which is great. I’d rather hear, “I just got a $10,000 bonus and don’t know what to do” than “I just got a $10,000 bonus and I bought bitcoin and went to Vegas!”

The questions usually revolve around how to divvy up the cash inflow in the most productive way possible, so I’m going to pose some absolute things to do as well as some things to think about here in this article that will hopefully help guide your next large cash inflow.

Navigate to what you need:

  1. Always, Always, Always…Pay Yourself First
  2. Now, It’s Time to Celebrate!
  3. Conclusions

Always, Always, Always…Pay Yourself First

I find it strange that most of us are willing to pay everyone else before we pay ourselves. Could you imagine if our employers did that? Paid all the bills EXCEPT salaries and no one got compensated?

Spending our money before saving is the exact same thing. We should strive to pay ourselves first, in the form of paying down debts or saving, and only then should we splurge on ourselves. We cover our bases so that “future me” isn’t picking up the pieces that “today me” left behind.

She clearly hasn’t read this article.

The percentages recommended are just that: recommendations. There are no hard and fast rules, but use the actions laid out below as guidelines to help yourself get started.

To-Do #1: Pay Down Debts

Most of us have a car with a loan on it, or furniture in our apartment or home that isn’t fully paid off yet, or student loan balances remaining. It’s okay to initially have debt like this in the sense that it helps to improve our quality of life, at least in theory. I need a car to get to my job every day, I like having somewhere to sit in my apartment, and my higher education advances my future career prospects.

However, as long as we have these debts, they are the primary source of quicksand our paychecks are subject to (aside from the U.S. government). This means less money going into our pockets because somebody else has a claim on our money that trumps our own claim on it.

Attitude Towards Debt Determines the Payment Method

When paying off debts, it’s important to understand our attitude towards the balances. Does the dollar amount bother us the most, or do the interest rates? There are two different methods for paying down debt and they revolve around the answers to this question: the snowball and avalanche methods.

I personally prefer the snowball method because I’d like to stop owing people money as fast as possible.

If the dollar amount bothers us, then we need to pay off the smallest loans first to feel a sense of accomplishment. This is the snowball method. Once we pay off a balance, we roll the payment onto the next lowest balance and continue until all debt is paid off.

If the interest rate bothers us, then we need to pay off the highest interest rate loan first. This is the avalanche method. This works for people who don’t like paying more money than they originally borrowed and are disciplined enough to stick with the payments, even if they don’t see any debt balances going to $0 in the short run.

ACTION: Decide how you feel about your debts and choose the method above that will best address your situation, and use 25% of your funds to pay them down.

To-Do #2: Fund Emergency Savings Account

Sometimes paying ourselves is as simple as having cash on hand to solve our immediate problems (not stuffed in our mattress or buried in the backyard somewhere, though). I talked in a previous post about the importance of having an account that has sufficient cash reserves for the inevitable “uh-oh” moments in life, and I’m going to reiterate that point here.

Funding this emergency account should be your next priority after paying down some debt. If you don’t have an emergency account, open a second checking account and get started.

Coins in a jar probably aren’t sufficient, either, but you get the idea.

How Much is Enough?

The general rule of thumb is to have 3 or 6 months of expenses sitting in cash. So, how do you know which is the right amount for you?

Ideally, if you’re single and have multiple income streams or are married with two solid incomes, then 3 months of expenses is probably sufficient. It’s easier to withstand hardships if multiple revenue sources are involved, so fewer reserves are required.

3 or 6 months is a rule of thumb, not a hard fast rule. Feeling financially secure is quantified differently for different people because it’s just that: a feeling.

On the other hand, if you are single or married with one source of income, then 6 months is an appropriate amount. A salary decrease or job loss is much more impactful if there is only one income source, so it’s smart to have a larger amount of dry powder on hand.

ACTION: Determine if you need 3 or 6 months of expenses in cash based on the criteria above and set that as a goal, using 25% of your bonus funds as a baseline.

To-Do #3: Contribute to Tax-Advantaged Accounts

A tax-advantaged account is so important to a financial plan because it allows us a tax break either today or in the future, or sometimes both. Congress designs the tax code around incentive structures so we’d be wise to take advantage of it where we can.

After we’ve paid down some debt and/or beefed up our emergency savings, we should look next to invest in tax-advantaged ways.

Fund a Roth IRA

In 2022, if we are single and make less than $129,000 ($138,000 in 2023) or are married and have a joint income less than $204,000 ($218,000 in 2023) then we are eligible to contribute directly to a Roth IRA. We are allowed a max $6,000 contribution ($6,500 in 2023) if under age 50, and $7,000 if we are over age 50 ($7,500 in 2023).

We always have access to our contributions in a Roth IRA because we contribute after-tax money into the account. Uncle Sam has already had his tax bite on those monies, so we’re allowed to withdraw our contributions if need be. This could act as our “backup” emergency account if we really had a tough day, but these monies generally should never be tapped.

It’s far more important in our youth to simply get started with tax-advantaged accounts rather than worrying about what ticker symbol to buy.

The next decision we have to make is how to invest our Roth IRA.

When we’re young and building up our asset base, it’s hard to get the proper diversification needed for a balanced portfolio simply because we don’t have enough money to spread around. Fortunately, it’s easy and cheap these days to put our money in an S&P 500 index fund and have access to thousands of companies inside one wrapper. This could be a place to start.

I’m not making any specific investment recommendations here, but I do recommend staying diversified if possible.

Fund an HSA

Healthcare isn’t cheap, and won’t be getting any cheaper in the future. If it makes sense for us to use an HSA to alleviate some of our future healthcare expenses, then we’d be wise to do so.

A Health Savings Account, or HSA, is a triple tax-advantaged way to save for healthcare expenses. It requires a High-Deductible Health Plan (HDHP) and allows us to contribute tax-deductible money into the account, invest it and have the earnings grow tax-free, and take it out of the account at any time for qualified health expenses, tax-free.

If we are single, we are allowed to contribute up to $3,650 ($3,850 in 2023) if under age 50, and $7,300 ($7,750 in 2023) if we are married and under age 50 in 2022. There are no income limits with HSAs, and just like the Roth IRA, there is a $1,000 catch up contribution allowed for those over age 50.

I will be writing a future post about the intricacies of HSAs but for now, if you have a HDHP and do not require consistent medical care, then an HSA could be a great fit for you. The investment options in an HSA are the same as a Roth IRA so I’d recommend investing them both the same way if you can.

Fund 529 Accounts

This may be a few years down the line depending on where you’re at in life, but 529 plans are great vehicles to kickstart college saving for a child, niece, or nephew. They are state-run savings plans that you fund with after-tax dollars and invest tax-free and withdraw tax-free for qualified higher education expenses (this tax treatment is similar to a Roth IRA, except the 529 funds have to be used for school expenses to receive the favorable tax treatment). The investment options are limited and are provided by the specific state the plan is in, but they tend to be broadly diversified funds.

I’ve only scratched the surface on the power of 529’s and it’s probably best to have a 529 at the bottom of your “paying myself first” list, but it is worth mentioning due to all of its great features.

ACTION: After paying off any debts and funding the emergency account, determine which of the above account(s) applies to your situation and set aside 25% of your funds to contribute.

Now, It’s Time to Celebrate!

To-Do #4: Treat Yourself!

Either you worked hard at your job to deserve the bonus, or you worked hard to get in Gam-Gam’s good graces to receive a cash gift from her, and in either case, you deserve to treat yourself!

The sooner we take care of our financial futures, the more flexibility we have to do the things we want in life. I’m a big believer in controlling our finances so they don’t control us, and that’s what the first 3 to-dos in this list consisted of.

But I also think it’s important that we reward ourselves for our hard work, recognizing that it’s okay to spend money on ourselves sometimes. As long as we cover our bases and take care of our future selves first, it’s perfectly reasonable to splurge a little.

Take a look at your budget and see how much you’d be comfortable spending on yourself. This could be new golf clubs, a mini vacation, a spa day, or a steak dinner. There’s no right answer on what constitutes “treating yourself”, but it’s unwise to spend more than your remaining bonus funds on whatever it is that you want (unless specifically budgeted for).

ACTION: Use your last 25% of your bonus to do something for yourself!

It’s that time of year for celebration so make sure you do it!

Conclusions

Year-end bonuses obviously improve our financial situations almost instantaneously, if we allocate the funds correctly. They tend to not be so useful if we take them to Vegas for a weekend, put it all on red, and wake up Monday morning not remembering what happened.

It’s important that we practice a bit of delayed gratification and first take care of the basics and help to ensure our financial longevity before splurging on gifts for ourselves.

But this doesn’t mean that we can never splurge, because we should! I think the beer ad disclaimer “please drink responsibly” applies here: treat yourself, but do so responsibly. Congratulate yourself on the hard work and have fun!

7 Key Ingredients For a Healthy Financial Plan in Your Youth

When I was eight, I didn’t like the food on my plate touching each other, especially at Thanksgiving. The peas couldn’t touch the carrots, which couldn’t touch the mashed potatoes, which couldn’t touch the turkey. Maybe I was an OCD eight-year-old but hopefully you can at least sympathize with me.

I now realize that a good dish has all the ingredients working together rather than remaining separate from each other (although I’m not suggesting jumbling your Thanksgiving dinner plate). Developing a financial plan works the same way and the sooner we integrate all elements of our financial lives the better off we’ll be.

Taking advantage of these opportunities in our youth allows us to avoid a lot of mistakes we’d otherwise make when we’re older. We take care of our bodies with healthy foods, so why not take care of ourselves with healthy financial habits?

Don’t want to read all the ingredients? Skip ahead:

  1. Develop a simple budget you can stick to
  2. Establish an emergency savings account
  3. Don’t take on more debt than you can afford
  4. Ensure you have proper insurance coverages for “the basics”
  5. Establish tax-advantaged dollars that benefit you long-term
  6. Impulse buying…don’t do it!
  7. KISS…Keep It Simple, Stupid!

Ingredient #1: Develop a simple budget you can stick to

When we start cooking a meal, we’re usually wise to start with good prep (making sure we have the right quantities of the right ingredients) before we even turn on the stove or BBQ.

A good budget (meaning one that is achievable but also allows us to live and have fun) is the foundation to financial independence.

The sooner we implement a budget that we can stick to, the more balanced and less stressful our life becomes.

“Today Us” vs. “Future Us”

I acknowledge that the word “budget” has a negative connotation and it’s met with instant resistance whenever it’s brought up. It might be helpful to think of a budget as the pathway to “future us” where we get to do all the things we want to do, rather than a restriction on the things “today us” wants to do.

Budgeting allows us to decide where our dollars go. If we aren’t aware and we consistently max out the credit card, we instead run the risk of Visa deciding where our dollars go (hint: it’s to them). It’s empowering to be in control of our financial life as opposed to our finances controlling us.

ACTION: Develop a budget that works for you. You can use an app like Mint (it’s free!) or if you’re a spreadsheet nerd like me, you can develop your own template in Excel or Google Sheets and track your monthly expenses. Decide what works best for you and get started.

Ingredient #2: Establish an emergency savings account

Now that our meal prep is done, it’s time to start cooking.

I’ll talk about how and where we should save our money in the coming steps but it’s important first to establish the need for saving. We can run the same thought experiment we did with budgeting and can think of saving as paying “future us” rather than taking away from “today us”.

It’s helpful to have some of these lying around if we’re in a pinch.

[Bleep], Now What?

The most important saving we can do in our youth is to establish an emergency savings account for the “[bleep], now what?” moments that will inevitably happen to us. This is an account that ideally has 3-6 months of fixed (rent, insurance, car/phone payments) and variable (food, clothing) expenses sitting in cash that we have quick access to.

It takes a while when we’re young to build up these savings but it’s important to “just get started.” Also keep in mind that this account is for actual emergencies…running out of beer during Sunday Night Football is not an emergency!

ACTION: Open a second checking account and set up automatic monthly or bi-monthly transfers from your main checking account. My personal setup is two days after each payday a little goes into my emergency account and I pretend that money never existed. 

Ingredient #3: Don’t take on more debt than you can afford

It’s always important to cook for the right amount of people and to not bite off more than we can chew!

Owing people money is generally not a good idea, especially if the interest rate on top of the money we owe is high. But there are a few good reasons to take on some debt in our youth that help us progress forward, like going to college or buying a house.

Student loan debt can be crippling if we don’t land a career that can help pay it off.

Not All Debt is Bad, But Be Cautious

Taking on debt in these situations makes sense if we can afford to make the payments. Taking out $200,000 in student loans to get a “14th century French literature” degree is probably not the wisest decision. Nor is buying a $1 million house when we’re making $50,000 a year at age 23.

Credit cards are another source of potential pain. While they are helpful for us to establish a solid credit score, most of them carry interest rates in the low-mid 20%’s which can sneak up on us if we forget to make a payment or two.

ACTION: Only take on as much debt as you can afford, and only do it when it makes sense. Pay off your credit card 2-3 days after you swipe if you can. This allows you to use the credit card to show activity while also increasing your credit score with timely payments…and racking up those juicy rewards points!

Ingredient #4: Ensure you have proper insurance coverages for “the basics”

A key ingredient in a healthy financial start that is often overlooked is how well we’re protected against potential disasters, however unlikely they may be.

Car, Health, and Life Insurances

“The basics” pertains to our car insurance, health insurance, and potentially life insurance if kids are in the picture. Other things like commercial liability or inland marine insurance are important, but beyond the scope of what we’re addressing here.

I get it, this stuff is boring and sometimes scary to think about. When we’re young, we don’t want to pay more for better insurance when we think, “but it’ll never happen to me!” We think we’re invincible in our youth…until we’re not.

Don’t Skimp on Coverage Limits

Most often, young people are either under-insured or have the wrong type of coverage. Buying the minimum amount of car insurance our state allows might save us a few dollars every month but won’t do us a lot of good if someone needs 2 prosthetic legs from an accident we caused.

If we’re young and in good health, we may also not need the more expensive health insurance plan our employer offers. A high-deductible health plan (HDHP) coupled with a Health Savings Accounts (HSA) is a cheaper and potentially more effective route for health coverage as it allows us to put away triple-tax advantaged money in an HSA while paying less for health insurance.

ACTION: Consider increasing your car insurance coverage to something like 300/500/100 if you can afford the monthly payments. You can also increase your comprehensive and collision deductibles to help offset the higher premium. Consider a HDHP if it’s available to you and couple it with an HSA to get more “qualified” dollars working for you.

Ingredient #5: Establish tax-advantaged dollars that benefit you long-term

Best not to wait. Source: BlackRock

Now we get to add some spice and flair to our meal without straying too far from the main recipe.

There are really two kinds of dollars we can save: those that are tax-advantaged (“qualified”) and those that aren’t (“taxable”). Qualified dollars are found in accounts like 401k’s, 403b’s, IRA’s and HSA’s and they enjoy tax-deferred growth. Taxable dollars are what’s in our checking and savings accounts, or brokerage account if we have one, and these dollars will be subject to capital gains taxes if we invest them.

Roth Dollars Reign Supreme

The dollars we contribute to qualified accounts are either taxed when we take them out (Traditional) or taxed when we contribute them (Roth). I’ll go out on a limb and say that with our country currently $31 trillion in debt, I doubt tax rates will be lower in the future.

So personally, I’d rather go the Roth route and pay a known tax rate up front on my 401k and IRA so every dollar in those accounts is mine when I retire. Regardless, it’s important to just get started as the penalty for waiting can be severe.

ACTION: Getting started with qualified accounts at this stage in our careers is more important than how much we put in them. Be sure you’re participating in your work retirement plan and if you’ve handled Ingredient #2, consider opening a Roth IRA and making small monthly contributions.

Ingredient #6: Impulse buying…don’t do it!

Imagine making the healthiest dinner ever and then ruining the health benefits by eating a massive piece of chocolate cake shortly after. Might not hurt us a few times, but a consistent habit of it will certainly degrade our health.

A good financial strategy that incorporates the ingredients above can be ruined with impulse buys of things that we think we need, but we really don’t. Whether they’re expensive things that we buy once or twice a month (but this jacket looks so good on me!), or a bunch of smaller expenses that we indulge in more often (sorry DoorDash), they both have the same effect of derailing our financial goals.

Discipline and developing a plan will reduce the likelihood of finances giving you this look.

Be Disciplined Now to Reduce Stress Later

It’s so easy to engage in these behaviors these days and we’ve all been there. I’ve been the victim of the one-click Amazon purchases and if you haven’t, you’re either lying or you’re more disciplined than the rest of us (reach out to me so I can study you).

Discipline is probably the most important trait when it comes to building wealth. It’s much easier to continue doing the same thing than it is to drop a habit and start a new one. If we develop good disciplinary habits early in our careers, then they will be easier to maintain and practice going forward when life inevitably gets more complex (more on that in the next ingredient).

ACTION: Always keep the budget you developed at the forefront of your mind when making large purchases. If you online shop, leave whatever you think you need in your cart for 72 hours. If you decide that you absolutely need it after the 72 hours are up, then buy it. If not, remove it from your cart and pat yourself on the back.

Ingredient #7: KISS…Keep It Simple, Stupid!

Any fans of “The Office” will know what this means. I doubt Michael Scott coined this acronym, but he’d probably tell you he did.

Keeping your financial life simple is the final ingredient that you sprinkle over the entire dish that really takes it to the next level.

Not All Information is Good Information

It’s easier than ever these days to have unprecedented access to information at our literal fingertips. A lot of the people producing this information have good intentions and want to arm society with knowledge to increase its odds of success (cue my “head-bow-with-hand-over-heart” action here). But there are always bad actors that we have to watch out for.

This usually comes in the form of someone selling you a low risk, high reward strategy, a flashy new product (hey Bitcoin!), or a “hot new stock”. Think about it…if you had a silver bullet to generate massive returns, why would you tell everyone? These kinds of things should make your spidey senses tingle. Don’t fall for it.

Turn Off The TV, Put the Phone Down, And Enjoy Life

Keep your life simple. The reality for us in our youth is that we can weather pretty much any storm that hits markets because time is on our side. We’re also broke enough that it’s hard to achieve proper diversification when we’re just starting out, so we’re better off throwing what few eggs we have into the S&P 500 basket and calling it a day.

S&P 500 performance 1960-2022
Who wouldn’t want to participate in this? Source: Yahoo! Finance, S&P 500 daily prices from 12/31/1960 to 12/7/2022. 7.03% annual return over the time period. Past performance not indicative of future results.

We’ve got more important fish to fry than worrying about what ticker symbol to gamble on. This is our time to explore the world, make memories with friends, and start our careers and families.

ACTION: Consider investing in the broader market rather than individual companies. Stay disciplined, stick to your gameplan, and don’t worry about short-term market movements. Play the long game and enjoy the things in life that make you happy.

The Final Recipe

Once we mix all seven ingredients and marvel at the healthy financial recipe we’ve just made, let’s not forget the last part: eat it! Cooking an awesome dish and then letting it sit and get cold doesn’t do anyone any good and developing a financial plan for ourselves is no different. Implementing the strategies we’ve developed for ourselves is rewarding and the sooner we get started, the more rewards we’ll have to reap!